Understanding the difference between Concrete and Abstract can make the difference between whether your story or video will better be remembered or forgotten. Although the video Logan Paul did on the suicide forest in Japan was controversial and caused him a good bit of hate before he took the video down, it is a good example of concrete vs. abstract.
It should be noted and understood that although concrete can be better remembered, our modern world is not a culture that particularly likes concrete over abstract because concrete can be more disturbing and harder to forget. Abstract can be more warm and fuzzy be remembered for the moment and then forgotten. It fits well with our throw away society.
_________________
18:21 / 21:36
Transcript
00:00
howdy and welcome to mighty muddy chuck
00:02
channel I’m Chuck have you ever wondered
00:05
about the difference between a concrete
00:07
memory and abstract memory a concrete
00:11
thought versus an abstract thought an
00:17
abstract thought is more likely to
00:19
present itself from the viewpoint of why
00:24
what is a concrete memory our thought is
00:31
more likely to present itself as how
00:38
that’s the difference between an
00:40
abstract thought and a concrete thought
00:43
now one thing to understand is a
00:45
concrete thought will stick with you
00:47
you’re more likely to remember a
00:52
concrete thought and episodic memory in
00:56
a memory as an episode of your life it
01:00
is the concrete thoughts that you’re
01:04
more likely to remember it’s the
01:06
concrete events that you’re more likely
01:08
to remember as you remember episodes in
01:11
your life abstract is more likely to be
01:15
more hazy because it’s it’s abstract is
01:21
hazy to start with it’s not it’s not
01:24
concrete it’s more foggy you’re less
01:28
certain of what’s happening you’re more
01:32
time you’re in a more confused state and
01:35
so you’re less likely to remember the
01:39
more abstract moments in your life now
01:46
if when Logan Paul had been doing the
01:48
video of when he went into the suicide
01:52
forest in Japan if he had done the video
01:56
where he only talked about seeing the
02:00
body or reacted to seeing the body that
02:04
would have been more abstract if he
02:07
didn’t show the body you would have
02:09
wondered is this some kind of joke you
02:12
would have a
02:13
thought is this real or isn’t it
02:17
you wouldn’t be sure the video would
02:20
have been more hazy because there have
02:25
been more questions regarding to what
02:27
exactly was going on in the video if
02:34
Logan Paul had not shown the body it
02:37
would not have impacted the viewer as
02:41
much it would not have affected the
02:44
viewer as much the viewer would not have
02:46
reacted as severely to what was
02:50
happening in the video because the video
02:53
would have remained more on that
02:54
abstract level and the truth is is a
02:58
week to two weeks from the time the
03:00
viewer saw the video that would be less
03:03
likely to remember that time that logo
03:05
Paul went into the suicide forest in
03:08
Japan and saw a body now there is a
03:12
contradiction between abstract and
03:15
concrete a level of fear can actually
03:19
make a very really vent a scary event
03:24
something that conduct it just affects
03:27
you it affects you in a major way to
03:32
where a concrete event that you’re in
03:36
becomes more abstract there is that that
03:43
contradiction there for example if
03:46
you’re giving a speech for example now
03:49
that’s in itself is not a big deal to a
03:51
lot of people some people you know they
03:53
get stage fright okay so say you’re
03:56
giving a speech and get real nervous you
04:03
almost feel sick at your stomach you’re
04:04
just it’s it’s it’s not pleasant so even
04:08
though you’re in that event in a real
04:11
way to deal with that stress you pull
04:15
yourself back into a more abstract mode
04:18
you may even project yourself to the
04:25
back of the auditorium
04:27
and for the back of the auditorium view
04:29
yourself giving the speech that’s
04:33
disassociation some people look at that
04:36
like a split personality type thing but
04:38
it’s actually it happens to people that
04:42
are not having severe mental issues it’s
04:44
just a level of stress it can cause you
04:47
to remove yourself from a situation to
04:51
make that situation more abstract so
04:54
that you feel like you’re not really
04:55
part of that event it’s a way that you
04:59
deal with stress and that’s a reason if
05:04
you’re in a stressful situation you may
05:08
have part of that memory maybe concrete
05:12
and you may remember part of that memory
05:16
as an episode and then a different part
05:21
of that memory even though it should be
05:23
concrete as well you’ve removed yourself
05:26
from the situation because it’s not
05:28
pleasant to you so it becomes abstract
05:30
so when you’re trying to remember an
05:32
episode it should be longer a longer
05:37
event in your life because it’s concrete
05:38
from you know the full length is
05:41
concrete you’ve removed yourself into an
05:44
abstract part so that you may remember
05:48
this part of the event there’s a memory
05:51
skip and then you remember another part
05:53
of the event and depending you know it
05:56
goes back to the level of stress or how
05:58
you’re dealing with it to the degree you
06:00
bring yourself back into the event or
06:02
the degree that you want to remove
06:03
yourself from the event so much that it
06:05
becomes abstract that’s the reason so
06:10
you’ve in episodic memory either as an
06:14
episode in your life you may remember
06:16
parts of that episode which is that a
06:18
fairly long episode you may remember
06:20
parts of it but there are memory skips
06:22
now some people reacted to Logan Paul’s
06:27
behavior when he saw the body and his
06:33
behavior to some degree did not come
06:36
across as real the little bits that I
06:38
saw of it now
06:40
let me remind you I didn’t see the full
06:41
video I only saw the parts that people
06:43
included in their videos where they were
06:45
being critical of it so I don’t really
06:48
know his full reaction to what was
06:52
happening but it was part of the
06:57
reaction that I saw you could pretty
06:58
much tell that he was removing himself
07:04
from the situation in other words he
07:09
wasn’t just trying to act goofy he went
07:12
into that mode to remove himself from
07:14
the situation it might be compared to
07:18
say that you go you have gone to the
07:20
funeral of someone that you care about
07:21
and did you love and it’s a highly
07:26
stressful event for you to go to their
07:28
funeral and and other people are in the
07:35
same situation that you’re in
07:38
so to distract yourself and they are
07:42
distracting themself removing themselves
07:45
you’re removing yourself from the
07:46
situation you might tell jokes you may
07:49
laugh that may come across as
07:54
disrespectful but it’s a coping
07:58
mechanism because you and they are in an
08:04
awful situation that you don’t want to
08:07
be happening you don’t want it to be
08:08
real you don’t want it to be concrete
08:12
you do not want it to be concrete
08:15
because you don’t want it to be real so
08:18
you go into another mode where you kind
08:22
of remove yourself from the situation
08:24
and you and they may kill jokes and you
08:27
may laugh many times you may bring
08:31
yourself back to the sense of the
08:33
reality of it and reflect on the life of
08:37
the person that you’re going to miss but
08:43
it’s a coping mechanism it’s it’s not
08:46
disrespect its removing yourself from
08:48
the situation and when it’s all over you
08:51
may not even pull it remember
08:53
that abstract moment of the event you
08:56
may mainly remember you feeling like
08:58
crying and you’re dying inside yourself
09:00
that may be what you remember you may
09:03
remember the part where it’s concrete
09:05
which real when you’re facing it and
09:07
you’re knowing it you may remember that
09:10
part of it but the part where you’re
09:13
trying to distract yourself from the
09:14
moment where you’re trying to make it
09:16
more abstract you may not even remember
09:19
that part of the event now of course
09:23
it’s possible as some people have
09:25
suggested that logan paul and his
09:29
entourage went there because they knew
09:32
there was going to be a body there they
09:34
had already in fact discovered the body
09:36
before the the videotaping at the
09:39
videotaping of you know finding the body
09:41
in other words it was kind of scripted
09:44
out and that’s possible too
09:47
but there again it’s still a coping
09:49
mechanism
09:56
it’s still coping mechanism mechanism
10:12
now some people are offended that he
10:18
showed the body or at least they pretend
10:24
they’re offended that he showed the body
10:29
but
10:37
understand by showing the body he took a
10:42
video that could have been primarily
10:44
abstract which you would have forgot
10:46
about in three days from the time you
10:51
clicked it up you’d already forgot about
10:52
it
10:54
if he kept the video abstract it would
10:57
have been forgettable by showing the
11:00
body he made it real his behavior aside
11:07
showing the body brought it into
11:10
concrete mode there was no one if
11:12
there’s a body there is now how would
11:15
people react if there was a body it
11:18
wasn’t him telling us a body there but
11:19
not showing the body by showing the body
11:22
he made something that could have been
11:24
abstract he made it real
11:27
he made it concrete he made it
11:29
unforgettable and it was there
11:39
and we live in a society they prefer
11:43
stuff abstract that prefers stuff fuzzy
11:46
that prefer stuff forgivable on some
11:52
level we as a society actually prefer
11:54
stuff that’s forgettable
11:58
it’s our throwaway Society but by making
12:05
the video concrete by making the video
12:10
less likely to be forgotten he brought
12:17
home a very serious issue suicide now it
12:24
may be a question to whether he was the
12:26
one that should have done the video and
12:29
I guess it’s a question to whether that
12:30
type of video belongs on YouTube but
12:37
it’s an issue that does need to be
12:40
discussed it’s an issue that does need
12:43
to be made real because too often when
12:46
the subject is talked about when suicide
12:48
has talked about it is put in at more
12:51
abstract terms let’s put in abstract
12:56
terms so you know in the abstract people
13:02
care in the concrete people realize it’s
13:07
a problem and they forget about it
13:12
now after Logan Paul did his video a lot
13:15
of people did their videos being
13:17
critical I didn’t really see any video
13:19
being positive about what he had done or
13:25
YouTube had done and I understand you
13:28
know that people feel like that Logan
13:31
Paul is treated special while other
13:34
channels are being knocked down by
13:36
YouTube you know demonetized and
13:39
censored in other ways and and this
13:42
makes people angry I understand that
13:44
part of it and I understand the part
13:49
that people reacted the way they reacted
13:51
because they did not
13:53
want it brought home real they did not
13:56
want it concrete in their memory they
13:59
wanted it’s something they could easily
14:02
forget about I know a lot of the people
14:06
that did the videos they you know they
14:11
present a lot they cared about the issue
14:12
of suicide and some of my guests did but
14:18
here’s the thing every video critical of
14:22
Logan Paul it’s forgettable totally
14:30
forgettable nobody’s gonna remember both
14:32
of those videos and yeah I know people
14:35
don’t remember well maybe the create the
14:40
level of cringe might make it so real
14:46
but I’m not critical of Logan Paul to be
14:55
honest i I’ve never really got into the
14:57
Paul brothers
15:01
I’m not saying as a put-down or like I’m
15:03
so cool octave cool for the power
15:05
brothers you know I’m not trying to put
15:08
them down I just you know there’s only X
15:13
amount of time in a day and I’m having
15:15
trouble getting things completed as it
15:17
is so I tend to watch PewDiePie let’s
15:26
note and he does some really good stuff
15:30
and some of them some of the videos were
15:32
actually longer which I have trouble
15:33
watch because I have trouble finding the
15:35
time to watch and but
15:44
but back to the point I’m not being
15:46
critical Logan Paul when he realized
15:57
that there were so many people upset
15:59
with the video he quickly brought it he
16:01
took it down YouTube didn’t remove the
16:02
video he removed the video and he
16:06
deserves credit for that he responded to
16:10
the criticism on his channel whether it
16:13
was right or wrong for him to do the
16:14
video he responded to the criticism and
16:16
he responded fairly quickly I think I’m
16:22
not critical of Logan Paul and he
16:24
brought forth an important issue and he
16:27
did it in a way that really you know
16:29
concrete concrete where the videos being
16:33
critical more abstract forgettable like
16:37
this video I’m dealing with more
16:39
abstract concepts
16:40
you might remember you might not for all
16:44
the long periods you won’t remember
16:46
which is unfortunate because I think I’m
16:49
making a valid point here it’s important
16:51
to understand you know the abstract
16:54
memory versus concrete memory and how
16:58
even a memory that’s concrete if your
17:01
level of fear is at a certain level that
17:05
it becomes abstract because you remove
17:08
yourself from the situation and
17:10
abstracts forgettable there are certain
17:12
things we just don’t want up here we
17:15
really don’t but at the same time didn’t
17:18
we start trying to analyze our episodic
17:20
memories and we realize our skips and
17:22
our memories and we realized we have
17:25
removed ourselves from certain
17:26
situations when the events were
17:28
happening now that this is true maybe
17:30
something happened wise 12 your Seldon
17:32
I’m not sure what I just I’ve got I’ve
17:35
got memories gifts between and of course
17:39
we start trying to feel and that’s gifts
17:41
that you’re likely to create false
17:42
memories and that’s a problem so you
17:43
don’t want to create false memories when
17:45
you start trying to fill in those blinds
17:47
and you’re trying to try to remember
17:48
abstract is very hard to remember once
17:51
you go into that abstract mode it’s
17:54
really hard to dig that back out and
17:56
it’s very
17:58
for whatever you dig out to be reliable
18:00
because when they’re skips
18:02
you’re likely to try to fill those skips
18:04
and sometimes what you’re trying to fill
18:07
those skips with what you’re trying to
18:08
rationalize in reason it’s more rifle
18:11
eyes and reason than actually
18:12
remembering and you just your memories
18:15
get muddled and you just not reliable a
18:18
hypnosis a lot of times it tries to fill
18:21
those skips it’s not reliable so anyway
18:29
I think it’s interesting I think the
18:34
memory you know want the one thing I
18:36
like about the discussion on the mental
18:38
effect is it does impart go to memory
18:41
you know whatever the full thing is you
18:46
know the fact that we do remember things
18:48
differently it does seem that certain
18:52
things change
18:54
it’s just weird but but even when you
19:00
get away from the supernatural and the
19:02
weirdness and and say this is a some
19:04
kind of digital computer program and
19:05
there’s glitches in the computer but you
19:07
can’t away from all that stuff just the
19:09
memory itself the way you remember stuff
19:11
and the way you deal with situations
19:13
it’s interesting in itself
19:15
so anyway much thanks for watching
19:18
listening and I do appreciate it don’t
19:22
be too hard on Logan Paul remember he’s
19:24
a living breathing creature care more
19:27
about the living than the dead care more
19:31
about the living than the dead and
19:34
there’s no reason to be mean to people
19:36
there’s no reason to be mean if you if
19:39
you didn’t like what Logan Paul did good
19:41
fine you know do your video and how you
19:43
don’t didn’t like what he did but don’t
19:45
be mean don’t be mean to the dude don’t
19:51
be jealous of the dude don’t be jealous
20:00
our success or failure here on YouTube
20:04
is our own my failure is my own I
20:08
understand that I think sometimes that
20:11
I’m being kind of knocked down by
20:13
outside forces I do and you know I get
20:17
into that mode sometimes my god I don’t
20:19
fully understand what’s going on why you
20:21
know this is whatever but at the end of
20:28
the day still my success or my failure
20:31
as a writer or are doing these videos is
20:36
my success or failure you know it’s it’s
20:39
me do it right or do it wrong it’s me
20:45
and I think that’s one really bad thing
20:48
about what YouTube is doing is because
20:52
we even when we kind of know it’s us
20:55
because of the shenanigans that they
20:57
pull it’s easy to want to blame them
21:02
when generally it’s still us you know
21:04
it’s still us it’s either felling or
21:06
succeeding it’s not them it’s not what
21:08
they’re doing to us but because they do
21:10
pull shenanigans and we do know they
21:12
pull shenanigans it’s real easy to get
21:15
in that mode and just play the blame
21:16
game
21:22
I just mistreat me so much no I’m not
21:26
gonna go in that mode whatever
21:28
shenanigans they pull it doesn’t matter
21:32
I’m not drawing traffic it’s me it’s not
21:35
them
